Ben Oliver

Now
This is the banner image for the article.
film

What Maisie Knew

Want to sleep with mommy tonight?
28 February 2015

Julianne Moore stars with Steve Coogan as neglectful parents of a young child. We follow the trials and tribulations of having different carers and different maternal and paternal figures.

What Maisie Knew has a couple of unique aspects. First, it’s rare to see such a story told through the eyes of a child without it being a children’s film. Maisie is often left on her own by her parents, but the camera barely ever looks away from her.

Second, events unfold in a low-key but unpredictable way. There’s material here that is almost screaming for a Hollywood style Julianne-Moore-crying-all-over-the-place melodrama, yet things seldom bubble over. There’s more of a drawn out melancholic air to the film; a bold move that mostly pays off.

Otherwise, this is an unremarkable film. Moore plays the rockstar mother well enough but sometimes comes over as a comedy villain. I’m not a fan of Coogan in dramatic roles and this only serves to validate my opinion - he’s a cliché of the philandering businessman who tries to pretend to care.

Alexander Skarsgård and Joanna Vanderham play the ‘back-up’ parents well, and they manage to sell their otherwise hackneyed story arc. Onata Aprile plays Maisie and nails the smart, observant but naive child character required of the role.

I like what What Maisie Knew is trying to do, but it fails to be the understated work of genius it wants to be.